Event details from: AIAS-HSI Seminar with Bryan Boyle

Date
27 October 2022
Time
11:00 – 12:00

Background

Despite success in scrutinising the interrelationship between the economic and the symbolic, sociology has only rarely considered the role that labour plays in status production (Sherman, 2011; Mears 2020). This includes whose theory of capital develops only an ambivalent appreciation of the role of labour and surplus in symbolic capital accumulation. As a step towards a labour theory of symbolic capital, this paper develops the relatively novel concept of the ‘labour of distinction’ by using the ‘butler’ occupation as a case study. The labour of distinction concept highlights how the ability of economically dominant groups to implement a distinct lifestyle may often depend upon specialised service labour. Incorporating findings from an ‘enactive ethnography’ (Wacquant, 2015) - which involved the author actually training at a butler school and working as a butler in private houses and at exclusive events in the UK – this paper develops and empirically grounds the ‘labour of distinction’ by identifying four of its key properties. These are: (1) Veblenian labour, labour geared towards (self-)producing the labourer’s body and embodiment per se as an object of the employer’s conspicuous consumption; (2) “Menial” labour, labour that undertakes necessary but ‘vulgar’ tasks so that employers can abstain from such for symbolic effect; (3) Curator labour, labour that is directly concerned with the aesthetic management and display of the employer’s class signifiers; and (4) Non-personship, the Goffmanian performance of being symbolically and socially absent whilst physically present as a method of alienating oneself from the distinct lifestyle one produces. Through the butler’s labour of distinction it can be seen how symbolic capital accumulation may entail labour processes in a way that Bourdieu’s model simply does not envision. In contrast to dominant approaches in Bourdieusian studies of work that focus on pre-entry or post-entry (dis)advantage (Rivera, 2015; Friedman & Laurison, 2020), the paper stresses the importance of exploitation at the intersection of the economic and symbolic.

Practical information

  • Date: Thursday 27 October 2022
  • Location: Roeterseiland Campus and online
  • Time: 11:00-12:00 hours

Questions

Do you have any questions? If so, please email us at aias-hsi@uva.nl. You can also register as a participant through this email address.